Become a Member

Regulation TrackerLaws, orders and treaties read for their security duties and clocks Standards & FrameworksAttack taxonomies, control catalogues and frontier frameworks AI Incident DatabaseThe security incident record, with mechanism and lesson Research Paper LibraryThe papers that define the field, summarised OSS DirectoryRed teaming, guardrail, supply chain and evaluation tools Case StudiesProgrammes built, with measured outcomes AI Vulnerability TrackerCVEs and advisories for the components AI systems are built from

Latest in the tracker

New York Stop Addictive Feeds Exploitation (SAFE) for Kids Act and implementing rulesNew York's law restricting algorithmic feeds for minors takes effect on 25 January 2027 under final rules published in July 2026, with certified age assurance and $5,000-per-violation penalties.

Knowledge Base Regulation Tracker Standards & Frameworks OSS Directory AI Incident Database Research Paper Library Case Studies Society Articles News Jobs About Charter Become a Member

Home/AI Incident Database/Robodebt: automated income-averaging raises unlawful welfare debts against hundreds of thousands of Australians

Robodebt: automated income-averaging raises unlawful welfare debts against hundreds of thousands of Australians

Australia's automated debt scheme reversed the burden of proof onto welfare recipients using a method the government knew was unlawful, causing widespread hardship and becoming the reference case for automation without oversight.

Under reviewSeverity: Highrobodebtaustraliawelfareroyal commission

At a glance

Organisation: Services Australia (Centrelink); Department of Human Services
Industry: Public sector
Country or region: Australia
Occurred: 1 Jul 2015
Disclosed: 27 Nov 2019
Type of harm: Wrongful denial of services or benefits, Psychological harm and self-harm, Regulatory penalties and legal liability

All details 13

Kind of system: Public sector and welfare AI
Severity: High
Confirmation: Established in court
Technique: Automated averaging of annual tax data to infer fortnightly overpayments without human review
Primary root cause: Missing human oversight
Scale: About 470,000 wrongful debts; A$1.8 billion settlement; suicides linked in evidence to the Royal Commission
Outcome: The Federal Court found the scheme unlawful, the government settled a class action for A$1.8 billion and a 2023 Royal Commission referred officials for prosecution and misconduct proceedings.

Sources

robodebt.royalcommission.gov.auhttps://robodebt.royalcommission.gov.au/

Contribute

Spot an error, or know a record we should add? Members can propose additions and submit corrections.

Submit incident Report a correction or request removal